Many have written this before: when it comes to sympathizing
with animals or people, animals always win.
·
NFL players beat wives and girlfriends, but only
Michael Vick still elicits protestors outside stadiums because of his dog fighting
past.
·
This ..\Pictures\child.jpg
image was a singular and world-wide tragedy, yet a ton of hard right
politicians and people in the US and Europe still won’t accept refugees, but
imagine if this body lying face down in the surf was an adorable baby hippo or
panda bear fleeing some torturous animal park or zoo?
·
Babies, and toddlers and mothers and fathers are
gunned down at staggering levels in the US to a collective national yawn, yet a
lion named Cecil, gunned down by a trophy-hunting dentist sets the internet on
fire in protest.
A few days ago, when Harambe,
the gorilla was shot in order to protect a child who had somehow gotten
into the enclosure, social media blew up with outrage at the parents, the zoo, and
the very practice of caging animals. It is now THE story in the world. More clicks and reads than the missing Air
Egypt plane, more attention than ongoing atrocities in the Middle East and
Africa, almost (imagine!) more attention than Donald Trump.
Why?
Why do we literally stop everything, place our outrage and
shock for human tragedies on hold and pick up our collective white-hot anger
for the perceived wronging of an animal? Why do we instantly forget about dying
kids, mutilated brothers and sisters, mangled corpses of once-thriving family
members, because some whale, primate or large cat is killed, imprisoned or
harmed by Homo sapiens?
I think I finally know why.
No, it’s not because of our humanity and kindness for
animals. No, it’s not because the innocence of animals strikes deep into our
hearts. No, it’s not because we hold ourselves to higher standards of
stewardship over the fauna of the earth.
We do it – we rage more against the killing and mistreatment
of animals vs. people because it’s easier.
At the end of the day, accounting for the endless violence
and mistreatment and hatred people inflict on other people is just too hard. In
response, we instantly latch onto the simplicity of people hurting animals.
In war, when a drone strike mistakenly takes out an innocent
wedding party, or US soldiers accidently shoot civilians, or bombs drift too
far afield and destroy a hospital, there exists significant complexity.
Complexity around the rules of war, the rules of engagement and the blurred
lines between civilian and enemy combatant.
With inner-city violence, there is complexity as well.
Complexity about guilt or innocence, the role of police, the role of guns and
the role of poverty.
In short, caring deeply about people we don’t know
personally is harder than caring for animals we’ve never met.
People come with faults and prejudices and meanness and
hate. Animals do not. There are many people who are “not on our team” – people
outside our class and station and ethnicity and nation of origin. Animals
aren’t on anyone’s team and therefore are benevolent free agents that we can
instantly care about.
If I care about a single young black teen gunned down on the
incredibly violent streets of Chicago, must I care about all street kids – even
thugs and gang-bangers? If I care about
massacred civilians in Syria, do I also have to care about the “bad guys” who
are legally targeted by our military? If I care about the wife or girlfriend
abused by a famous athlete, must I care about all victims of domestic abuse,
even if they live in my neighborhood or are a part of my own inner-circle? For
many people, that gets complicated very quickly.
But caring about a lovable gorilla, or a majestic lion, or a
stable of fighting dogs? That’s easy.
The same calculous that makes it so difficult to really care
about unknown humans works fine with animals.
We can care about the euthanized gorilla, because we can care about ALL
gorillas. We are decidedly pro gorilla
and there are no exceptions or caveats with that caring.
Because no gorilla ever did us wrong, we can go ahead and
love them all. No strings attached.
Yet isn’t it strange that unconditional love is really only
paid out by us when it comes to inter-species affection. As people, we find it
so much easy to care for animals then our own kind.