I had no real rooting interest in the Super Bowl. I am a fan
of neither the Patriots nor the Falcons, but it certainly was a highly
entertaining game for any football fan to witness. Entertaining because of the
amazing way New England came from behind, and the amazing way Atlanta imploded.
And as any true fan of NFL football knows inherently down to
their core – the Atlanta Falcons are doomed at least in the short term. For
every true fan knows with the certitude of knowing the sun will rise tomorrow –
the Falcons will not make it back to the Big Game next year. Further, their
odds of even making the playoffs are very, very steep. History has shown with
the clarity of the Arctic Ocean that if you lose the Super Bowl, you will not
return the next year and most likely years later as well. It is as certain as
death and taxes.
And when you couple this iron-clad fact with the historical
choke job turned in by the loser of Super Bowl 51, the fate of Atlanta is
sealed for at least the next five to seven years easy.
Yet, beginning the day after their historic loss, and
continuing right on through next season, everyone who should know better: the
owner, the GM, the coach, the players and the professional prognosticators will
all join in unison to try and convince the world of alternate facts. That the
Falcons will get back to work and launch a realistic campaign to represent the
NFC in Super Bowl 52. Instead of admitting reality and engaging in a strategy
of deep and profound change, they will all stick to the tried and true
delusional path of “retool and reload.”
History screams for the Falcons to make bold changes and
massive shifts. But they won’t.
The reason they won’t is simple yet profoundly frustrating. The
NFL is an organization ruled by fear of the unconventional. It’s why coaches
don’t go for it a lot more on 4th down and why GM’s continue to hire
retread coaches, and why franchises always copy what the Super Bowl winner of
the previous year has done. Owners and GM’s and coaches live in fear of being
second-guessed by fans or whoever signs their checks. For most leaders in the
NFL, losing is not as costly as going against the grain.
Therefore, what the Falcons should do – but won’t - is to embrace their fate and use the next
several seasons to completely rebuild so that they are in a much better
position to compete for a championship sooner rather than later.
And that rebuild must start with the man most responsible
for their historic loss.
The Falcons have an MVP quarterback in Matt Ryan. He tore up
the NFL this year, despite a history which seems to strongly suggest he is a big
moment choker throughout nine years in the league. He is also 31-years-old. He
will be 36 to 38-years old when the Falcons emerge from the purgatory between Super
Bowl loss and return to prominence. Therefore, the next step for the Falcons is
crystal clear: trade Ryan while he is at the height of his value, yet on the
downside of his longevity, to a QB-starved organization with valuable assets.
“Trade an MVP, all-pro quarterback at the height of his
career?! That crazy!,” you might say.
No, sorry, it’s not. The secret formula to win an NFL
championship is a relatively simple math equation that can be expressed as
such:
Good coach + cohesive and talented
players + great quarterback/time = Championship.
Of course every fan knows you need good coaching, good
players and a good QB, but what every NFL franchise often refuses to
acknowledge is that every team has a narrow window of opportunity with which to
exploit that good coach, good players and good quarterback. Further, the window
on the QB is the smallest. After all, a coach can last for a decades, a quality
franchise will always continue to restock with good players, but the window for
a good QB is fairly short and to make it even more precious that window of time
is divided into thirds where only about 33 percent of his career is available
for a championship run.
Here’s how it looks. The first third is the learning curve
years, say one to four where your QB is figuring out how to be great. Years
five through eight are the prime seasons with which to take a shot at the brass
ring of a Super Bowl. Years nine through 12 is the decline. Matt Ryan is now in
the decline period. And Ryan enters the decline period at the same time his
team is entering the Bermuda Triangle of Super Bowl Loser.
For the Falcons, the best chance they have for getting back
to the Super Bowl is to embrace the hole they’ve dug for themselves by losing
to the Patriots. They shouldn’t fight against history’s gravitational pull as
Super Bowl loser. They are going to be wandering in the wilderness for the next
several years – that is assured by their loss. They should use that time
wandering to build better, younger and cheaper assets to make that run up the
hill again. They shouldn’t squander their exile by denying they are in exile. They
are wearing the scarlet letters “SBL” for Super Bowl Loser. They should use
this time as outcasts to recast their future.
Unfortunately, their owner, their GM and their coach won’t
do what is needed because they fear the backlash of taking the bold and
unconventional path. And so, the Falcons will most assuredly limp along for the
better part of a decade putting together, 8-8, 9-7 and 7-9 seasons with the
occasional 10-6 and first round playoff loss mixed in.
Bad times ahead for the good people of Atlanta.
And speaking of bad times…let’s talk about another team that
has been battered recently – the democrats.
In many ways, the democrats are a lot like the Super Bowl
loser; blithely continuing forward under the delusion that business as usual is
the correct strategy to pursue.
In 2016 the democrats got their teeth kicked in. They got
their teeth kicked in because their leadership is old, out of touch and
unwilling to embrace new ways. The 2016 election was the Super Bowl, and the
democrats lost. I don’t know if that means they are doomed to fail in the next
big game – the 2020 presidential election - but I do think the analogy is apt.
The Falcons will not win a championship in the near future and therefore must
fundamentally chance course. Similarly, the democrats are going to be out of
power for several years and must also fundamentally change course.
For the Falcons, that means trading Matt Ryan and for the
democrats, that means trading their current leadership for younger, hungrier
and more entrepreneurial leaders.
Under the current leadership of Nancy Pelosi, Chuck Schumer,
Harry Read and others, the democrats have lost everything. The House, the
Senate, the presidency and most states – gone. Further they will continue to
seat a minority on the Supreme Court. If the Falcons second half collapse was
historic, so too has been the democrats collapse last year.
And just like Atlanta’s future, the democrat’s future hinges
on bold, unconventional action. Trading their MVP quarterback during this
window of opportunity is critical for the Falcon’s future. Replacing their
tired war-horses for fresh blood and new ideas is critical to the democrat’s.
I fear however, that the democrats – like NFL franchises -
are paralyzed by their fear of unconventional thinking. Instead of looking at
the results of their shocking 2016 losses and admitting that a massive change
in course is needed - right now - they will dither.
The good news for both the Falcons and the democrats? Their
competition is flawed as well. The other teams in the NFL and the other
political party are just as prone to screw things up. Their time will come
again – for the Falcons they will amass the right combination of coach, team
and quarterback to make another run and for the democrats they will amass the
right combination of leaders, ideas and message to recapture power.
For both, I’m afraid it’s just a matter of later rather than
sooner.